page001 |
Previous | 1 of 8 | Next |
|
|
Loading content ...
A Critical Analysis of Warburg Respirometry For BO D Determinations of Polluted Waters T.J. TUFFEY, Assistant Professor J.V. HUNTER, Professor Rutgers University New Brunswick, New Jersey 08903 J.P. HEWITT, Environmental Scientist EBASCO Services, Inc. New York, New York INTRODUCTION Warburg respirometry has been successfully used to measure carbonaceous BODs on samples of moderate to high concentration. These would include wastewaters of domestic and industrial origin. This technique is also effective in studies of a comparative nature, i.e., as in determining the i oxicity of potential feed stocks on activated sludge or ascertaining the treatability or bioavailability of new products. More detailed discussion of these topics is available (1). In this paper an evaluation is made of the applicability of Warburg respirometry in determining the low levels of BOD found in polluted rivers. Errors that would be insignificant when dealing with BODs of 100 mg/1 or greater become very important in BODs less than 10 mg/1. This paper compares the error of the Warburg technique to that of a technique employing standard BOD bottles and a dissolved oxygen probe. Only carbonaceous BOD is considered. The potential for significant levels of nitrification exists in nearly all polluted waters. A critical objective of this research is to determine how accurately that evidence of nitrification obtained by Warburg respirometry depicts that actually occurring in the water bodies sampled. Is the physical environment of the Warburg flask so different from that environment the nitrifying bacteria are exposed to in situ that they exhibit non- representative growth patterns? EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURES In all studies, Aminco Warburg respirometers were used with 125 ml flasks and 50 ml sample volumes. 1 ml of 15% KOH was placed in the center well as a C02 absorbent. Temperature was maintained at 20 C for the duration of the runs, usually 15-20 days. Standard operating procedure consisted of equilibrating the sample to 20 C and aerating it to saturation. Manometer readings were recorded to the nearest mm and incubation time to the nearest 0.01 days for the studies on statistical variability but only to the nearest day for the nitrification work. In order to determine the variances of the two BOD techniques, nitrification inhibited samples, unhibited samples, and thermo-barometers were incubated in triplicate. Inhibition was achieved with 0.5 mg/1 of allylthiourea replenished at 7 day intervals. Inhibited and uninhibited samples were also incubated in triplicate at 20 C with the BOD bottle technique. Standard 300 ml BOD bottles were used and DO was recorded to the nearest 0.02 mg/1 with a Weston-Stack DO probe calibrated daily against the Winkler (2). During the measurement of the DO a small volume of sample was lost, less than 1 ml; this was replaced by adding 1 ml of a similarly incubated sample. The 1 ml addition allowed the BOD bottle to be resealed without trapping air. DO was maintained above 2 mg/1 at all times by pulling low DO bottles off line and aerating them.
Object Description
Purdue Identification Number | ETRIWC197401 |
Title | Critical analysis of Warburg respirometry for BOD determinations of polluted waters |
Author |
Tuffey, T. J. Hewitt, J. P. |
Date of Original | 1974 |
Conference Title | Proceedings of the 29th Industrial Waste Conference |
Conference Front Matter (copy and paste) | http://earchives.lib.purdue.edu/u?/engext,24462 |
Extent of Original | p. 1-8 |
Series | Engineering extension series no. 145 |
Collection Title | Engineering Technical Reports Collection, Purdue University |
Repository | Purdue University Libraries |
Rights Statement | Digital object copyright Purdue University. All rights reserved. |
Language | eng |
Type (DCMI) | text |
Format | JP2 |
Date Digitized | 2009-06-04 |
Capture Device | Fujitsu fi-5650C |
Capture Details | ScandAll 21 |
Resolution | 300 ppi |
Color Depth | 8 bit |
Description
Title | page001 |
Collection Title | Engineering Technical Reports Collection, Purdue University |
Repository | Purdue University Libraries |
Rights Statement | Digital object copyright Purdue University. All rights reserved. |
Language | eng |
Type (DCMI) | text |
Format | JP2 |
Capture Device | Fujitsu fi-5650C |
Capture Details | ScandAll 21 |
Transcript | A Critical Analysis of Warburg Respirometry For BO D Determinations of Polluted Waters T.J. TUFFEY, Assistant Professor J.V. HUNTER, Professor Rutgers University New Brunswick, New Jersey 08903 J.P. HEWITT, Environmental Scientist EBASCO Services, Inc. New York, New York INTRODUCTION Warburg respirometry has been successfully used to measure carbonaceous BODs on samples of moderate to high concentration. These would include wastewaters of domestic and industrial origin. This technique is also effective in studies of a comparative nature, i.e., as in determining the i oxicity of potential feed stocks on activated sludge or ascertaining the treatability or bioavailability of new products. More detailed discussion of these topics is available (1). In this paper an evaluation is made of the applicability of Warburg respirometry in determining the low levels of BOD found in polluted rivers. Errors that would be insignificant when dealing with BODs of 100 mg/1 or greater become very important in BODs less than 10 mg/1. This paper compares the error of the Warburg technique to that of a technique employing standard BOD bottles and a dissolved oxygen probe. Only carbonaceous BOD is considered. The potential for significant levels of nitrification exists in nearly all polluted waters. A critical objective of this research is to determine how accurately that evidence of nitrification obtained by Warburg respirometry depicts that actually occurring in the water bodies sampled. Is the physical environment of the Warburg flask so different from that environment the nitrifying bacteria are exposed to in situ that they exhibit non- representative growth patterns? EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURES In all studies, Aminco Warburg respirometers were used with 125 ml flasks and 50 ml sample volumes. 1 ml of 15% KOH was placed in the center well as a C02 absorbent. Temperature was maintained at 20 C for the duration of the runs, usually 15-20 days. Standard operating procedure consisted of equilibrating the sample to 20 C and aerating it to saturation. Manometer readings were recorded to the nearest mm and incubation time to the nearest 0.01 days for the studies on statistical variability but only to the nearest day for the nitrification work. In order to determine the variances of the two BOD techniques, nitrification inhibited samples, unhibited samples, and thermo-barometers were incubated in triplicate. Inhibition was achieved with 0.5 mg/1 of allylthiourea replenished at 7 day intervals. Inhibited and uninhibited samples were also incubated in triplicate at 20 C with the BOD bottle technique. Standard 300 ml BOD bottles were used and DO was recorded to the nearest 0.02 mg/1 with a Weston-Stack DO probe calibrated daily against the Winkler (2). During the measurement of the DO a small volume of sample was lost, less than 1 ml; this was replaced by adding 1 ml of a similarly incubated sample. The 1 ml addition allowed the BOD bottle to be resealed without trapping air. DO was maintained above 2 mg/1 at all times by pulling low DO bottles off line and aerating them. |
Resolution | 300 ppi |
Color Depth | 8 bit |
Tags
Comments
Post a Comment for page001